Sometimes sport and in this case football, shines a light on something much bigger.
At the Azteca Stadium on Sunday evening everything that is great about football was present. Two teams giving their all, two sets of supporters getting behind their teams and passion and commitment from, all in spades. Everything was left, by every player on the field. Sport at its very best.
Indeed, this World Cup has delivered some amazing games of football as anyone who watched Cape Verde play Argentina would testify.
But yesterday it was all about a red card, and not the one awarded to Jarell Quansah.
We woke up on Monday in a mix of daze and disbelief. We were both mildly exhausted but wanted to meet up with our friends. So we found the bar that Mark, Reg, Spanish Dave and Obi were in to watch the Spain vs Portugal game. The bar turned out to be the Mexican version of Fawlty Towers. They were clearly overrun, didn’t have enough experienced staff and their systems seemed to be ‘down’. It reflected the game really, which came and went. Two incredibly talented teams doing precisely the opposite to what Mexico and England had done the night before. This game was no bang and all whimper.

The main topic of conversation amongst us however, was the rescinding of Balogun’s red card for Team USA as a result of the reports of multiple conversations between President Donald Trump and FIFA President Gianni Infantino where the US President had asked for the decision to be reviewed. The one match suspension which follows a red card was then ‘suspended for a year’ citing some obscure FIFA rule, allowing one of America’s best players to take his place in the biggest match the United States had played for years.
Good piece here from ITV
https://youtu.be/pQXRxJmS-WU?is=jeEokmW9h6_rDf1Z
Coincidentally, the same trick had been pulled by FIFA to suspend Ronaldo’s red card playing for Portugal in a World Cup qualifier so that he could play in the opening games of this World Cup. ‘No Ronny, no money’?
Our discussion wasn’t centred on whether Folarin Balogun deserved to be sent off. Football supporters will argue about decisions until the end of time. That’s what we do. Some think it was harsh. Others think it was obvious. VAR gives us endless opportunities to disagree.
No, what fascinated us wasn’t the decision. It was everything that had happened afterwards.
Whether you think Balogun should have been available or not almost misses the point. The question is actually much simpler.
Would that have happened if the player had been Belgian? Or Norwegian? Or Ghanaian? Or from Cape Verde? Or a New Zealander?
Of course not. And that is the uncomfortable truth.
For generations America has projected itself as one of the world’s champion of rules, institutions and fair play. A country that exported constitutional government, independent courts and sporting competition built on the principle that everyone starts at 0-0.
Yet increasingly it appears to be embracing a different philosophy. If the rules don’t produce the result you want, challenge the rules. If that doesn’t work, challenge the referee. If that doesn’t work, challenge the institution.
And if all else fails, use influence.
That isn’t uniquely American, of course. Every country has flirted with that temptation. Every powerful individual has occasionally believed they deserve different treatment.
But when the most powerful nation on earth begins normalising that approach, the implications reach far beyond the beautiful game of football.
Because institutions can only work when everyone believes the same rules apply to everyone. The irony is that America became a superpower precisely because investors, businesses and allies trusted its institutions more than its politicians. Presidents came and went. Congress changed hands. Judges retired. Yet the system endured because the rules mattered more than the individuals.
That confidence has been one of America’s greatest export. Far greater than Hollywood. Far greater than Silicon Valley. Far greater than the US dollar.
Trust. Once that begins to erode, it is remarkably difficult to rebuild. Football and football fans understand this instinctively. Us supporters can accept losing, let’s face it we have plenty of experience in that department. We can accept poor refereeing. We can even accept bad luck. But what we cannot accept is believing the game has been tilted.
The moment supporters think one team is playing by different rules, something precious disappears.It isn’t simply unfair. It stops feeling like sport.
Perhaps that’s why this story resonated so widely with all of us. It wasn’t about a tackle. It wasn’t even about FIFA. It was about whether influence should ever outweigh process. Whether power should ever trump principle.
Whether the biggest nations should receive treatment unavailable to everyone else.
We took a break after the Spanish victory over Portugal and re-convened in a lovely little bar called Tap Room Dos Aves. Reg, Mark, Obi, Cass, Billy, Spanish Dave, Supes, Mark, Sam and Kirsty assembled and enjoyed the very relaxed vibe.
I don’t think it was a secret that all of us were now rooting for Belgium purely and simply because of the mess that Trump and Infantino had inflicted on our World Cup. Up until now the USA had played with pace and aggression and I thought they would beat the Belgians.
Americans had embraced the football and the World Cup in general. The USA had really got some great press and media coverage because they had done a good job with their third of the hosting duties. That soft power is so important. Mexico and Canada have gained loads of it too.
Team USA’s young and talented players had built a clear and very effective identity under the genius that is Mauricio Pochettino. All that was up in the air now. How would those US players react to this frankly ludicrous situation? How would the much maligned Belgian squad react to this? This is the kind of thing that brings teams together.
As we watched the game it was clear that something had changed. Team USA were a shadow of their former selves. Belgium rose to the occasion, scoring an early goal. It got worse and worse for Team USA. The majority of our bar were behind Team USA and we couldn’t help ourselves by cheering every one of the four Belgian goals. That would not have happened last week. Pure and simple.

I thought of all the really good American football fans I had met these past three weeks. What must they have been thinking at the end of this? They really don’t deserve this.
Belgium won the game convincingly 4-1 and the footballing debate moves on.
But the constitutional debate won’t. Because the real red card wasn’t shown on the pitch. It was shown to the idea that institutions should be bigger than the people who happen to lead them. History suggests that’s a game no country can afford to lose.
It really is a shame that Team USA have exited the World Cup. Those players and manager did not deserve such an ignominious end to what had been a triumph of their will and endeavour.

And if ever a country’s leader scored an own goal, today this bloke did it, not once, but four times. Who’s the loser now?





























































































